When your shower starts looking a little worse for wear, it’s easy to assume you need a total overhaul. But before you start looking at new tile samples, it’s worth asking: Does the tile need to go, or does the grout just need a rescue?

At Straightline Grout, we see this dilemma all the time across the Metroplex. Here is how to tell which path is right for your bathroom.

When to Regrout (The Restoration Path)

Regrouting is the process of removing the old, damaged grout and replacing it with fresh material without disturbing the tile. This is often the best move if your tile is still in good shape but the “grid” is failing.

Signs you should regrout:

Discoloration: Your grout is stained or dark despite deep cleaning.
Minor Cracking: Small cracks are appearing in the grout lines, but the tiles are still firmly attached to the wall.
The “Dated” Look: You love your tile, but the grout color feels stuck in the 90s. A fresh color seal or regrout can modernize the entire room.
Budget & Time: Regrouting is significantly faster and more cost-effective than a full retile. Most of our shower restorations are finished in just a day or two.

When to Retile (The Replacement Path)

Sometimes, the issue goes deeper than the surface. If the structural integrity of the shower is compromised, no amount of new grout will fix it.

Signs you should retile:

Loose or Hollow Tiles: If you tap a tile and it sounds hollow, or if it moves when you press it, the “mud” or thin-set behind it has failed.
Water Damage: If you see signs of mold behind the tiles or soft spots in the drywall/backer board, the waterproofing is gone. This requires a tear-out to fix it correctly.
Major Cracks: If there are long cracks running through the tiles themselves (not just the grout), it often indicates the house is shifting or the subfloor is unstable.
Total Style Change: If you simply can’t stand the look of the tile anymore, it’s time for a fresh start.

The Straightline Recommendation

If your tiles are solid and the waterproofing is intact, regrouting and professional sealing provide a massive “bang for your buck.” It restores the “like-new” look and protects your home from moisture for years to come.

However, if your shower is “crunchy” or leaking, a restoration is just a band-aid. In those cases, we recommend a full retile to ensure your home’s structure remains protected.

Need an Expert Opinion?

Not sure which one you need? Don’t guess and risk water damage.

Text us a photo of your shower at 469-715-7656 or schedule a free estimate today. We’ll give you a straight answer on whether a restoration or a full remodel with our partners at Elite Stoneworks is the best move for your DFW home.